What is the Best IP Camera: PTZ or Panoramic
PTZ and Panoramic surveillance cameras provide a wide viewing area but do it differently. This difference is important. Two popular options for surveillance cameras are PTZ (Pan-Tilt-Zoom) and Panoramic cameras. Each has strengths and limitations, depending on factors like viewing distance, low-light performance, situational awareness, critical situation detection, and best applications.
This article compares the performance and applications of each type of surveillance camera.
Review of Panoramic and PTZ Cameras
The IP Panoramic and PTZ cameras are designed to view large fields of view, but they do it differently.
Panoramic Cameras
The Panoramic IP camera provides a very wide, uninterrupted view in all directions. It can be achieved using a single sensor or an array of sensors (or cameras). Single-sensor 360-degree or fisheye cameras have been around for many years. The problem with panoramic cameras has always been the lack of detail available at a distance. The latest high-resolution cameras and multi-sensor cameras provide much better resolution. To learn more about the types of panoramic cameras, please read our article Comparison of Panoramic IP Cameras.
PTZ (Pan, Tilt, Zoom) Cameras
An IP Pan, Tilt, Zoom (PTZ) camera is a network-attached video camera that can move under the control of a computer mouse, joystick, or software or in an automatic patrol mode. It can move left and right (pan) and up and down (tilt). It also includes a zoom lens that can be remotely controlled from the Video Management Software (VMS) or Network Video Recorder (NVR). Many of the new PTZ cameras include an IR illuminator for seeing in total darkness. To learn more about the PTZ camera, please read our article, The Evolution of the PTZ Camera.
AI-Enhanced Panoramic and PTZ Cameras
AI enhancement has improved the capability of both the PZ and Panoramic cameras. To learn more, please read our discussion of AI-Enhanced IP Camera Systems.
Comparison of PTZ versus Panoramic Cameras
The ability to recognize a person is critical in many situations. Identifying a person you know is easier than one you don’t know. In many cases, you can identify a person not only by their face but also by the clothes they wear and how they walk. The police would like a more objective (or forensic) identification. Forensic identification provides enough detail to compare the video to a picture of a person’s face. You need much more resolution to identify a person you don’t know. To learn more about resolution requirements, please read our article, What IP Camera Resolution Do You Need?
Effective Viewing Distance for Face Identification
The resolution required to identify a person is estimated at 70 to 80 pixels across the face. The camera resolution and the field of view determined by the lens, establishes the detail you can see. The wider the view, the fewer pixels across the face. A wide-angle camera, such as a panoramic camera, provides less detail than the PTZ camera, which can zoom in and give a narrow field of view.
PTZ Cameras:
- PTZ cameras excel in identifying faces at long distances, thanks to their optical zoom capabilities (e.g., 10x, 20x, or more).
- The ability to zoom in and focus on specific areas makes PTZ cameras ideal for recognizing faces or license plates in large, open spaces such as parking lots or stadiums. A PTZ camera with an optical zoom of 125X and a 2,000 mm zoom lens can identify a person over one mile away.
- However, this focused view means other areas are left unmonitored while zooming in.
Panoramic Cameras:
- Panoramic cameras, especially 360-degree or fisheye models, offer a wider field of view but lack optical zoom.
- Facial identification is only effective at shorter distances due to the limited resolution per area within the broad view. For example, cameras with multiple sensors can identify a person’s face at less than 20 ft.
- Ideal for spaces where multiple areas must be monitored simultaneously, but not for long-range identification.
Winner: PTZ cameras for long-distance identification; panoramic cameras for close-range, wide-area coverage.
Low-Light Applications
PTZ Cameras:
- Many PTZ models are equipped with infrared (IR) lighting and low-light enhancement technologies (e.g., starlight sensors), allowing them to capture detailed images in darkness or near-dark conditions.
- Optical zoom maintains clarity even in low-light settings.
- Specialized long-range PTZ cameras include optical and thermal imaging cameras, which means they can operate in total darkness.
Panoramic Cameras:
- Some Panoramic cameras use multiple sensors to provide better resolution and low-light environments, but their fixed lens design limits their ability to enhance distant details in low light.
- Some panoramic cameras also include IR illumination, but the broader field of view can dilute IR effectiveness.
Winner: PTZ cameras for superior low-light performance and long-distance clarity.
Situational Awareness
PTZ Cameras:
- PTZ cameras provide detailed views of specific areas, but their narrow focus limits situational awareness.
- If the camera is zoomed in or panned toward one area, other sections are left unmonitored unless additional cameras are deployed.
- Some PTZ cameras and the Video Management Software provide automated patrol modes where the camera steps through predetermined positions. This can help create a wider range of view.
Panoramic Cameras:
- Panoramic cameras are unmatched for situational awareness, capturing a 360-degree field of view in real-time.
- These cameras provide a comprehensive perspective, allowing operators to simultaneously monitor multiple points of interest without missing any activity.
Winner: Panoramic cameras for broad situational awareness.
Best Applications for Each Type of IP Camera
PTZ Cameras:
- Large Outdoor Areas: Ideal for parking lots, stadiums, highways, and airports where long-range zoom is necessary.
- Perimeter Security: Effective for tracking individuals or vehicles along a facility’s perimeter.
- Active Monitoring: Suitable for environments with security personnel actively operating the cameras to follow suspicious activity.
Panoramic Cameras:
- Indoor Spaces: Perfect for retail stores, lobbies, and warehouses where 360-degree coverage is beneficial.
- Situational Awareness: This is useful in environments like train stations, public squares, or event venues to monitor large crowds and detect incidents.
- Cost-Efficiency: Panoramic cameras reduce the need for multiple cameras in small to medium-sized spaces.
Comparison Table of PTZ and Panoramic Cameras
| Feature | PTZ Cameras | Panoramic Cameras |
| Viewing Distance | Long-range zoom for facial identification | Close-range facial clarity, limited zoom |
| Low-Light Performance | Excellent with IR and starlight sensors | Moderate, limited by broader coverage |
| Situational Awareness | Focused, narrow view | Wide, 360-degree view |
| Critical Situation Detection | Detailed tracking of individuals | Broad anomaly detection |
| Best Applications | Large outdoor areas, active monitoring | Indoor spaces, wide-area coverage |
Conclusion
Choosing between a PTZ camera and a panoramic camera depends on the security needs of your application:
- Select the PTZ camera if your priority is detailed, long-range observation, especially in outdoor or perimeter settings where zoom and tracking are essential.
- Choose a panoramic camera for situational awareness and wide-area coverage, particularly in indoor or public spaces.
Both types of cameras have strengths, and integrating them within a comprehensive surveillance system can offer the best of both worlds.
If you want help selecting the best IP Camera System, please call us at 1-800-431-1658 in the USA or 914-944-3425 worldwide or use our contact form.